In coastal areas such as Dorset, there is growing concern that landlords are stepping away from traditional private renting and turning instead to short-term holiday accommodation. It is an understandable fear. In places with strong tourism demand, holiday lets can appear to offer more flexibility, higher peak-season income, and fewer of the pressures associated with long-term tenancies.
But the picture is more complicated than the headline suggests.
There is clear evidence that many landlords are considering reducing their exposure to the private rented sector. What is much less clear is whether large numbers are definitely switching into short-term holiday lets, rather than simply selling up, restructuring their investments, or leaving the market altogether.
Landlords are clearly feeling pressure
Across England, a growing number of landlords have said they intend to reduce the size of their portfolios over the next couple of years, with a notable share saying they plan to sell all of their rental properties. That points to a sector under strain.
The main reasons behind this appear to be consistent across the market. Landlords are facing:
- higher mortgage costs
- tax changes that have reduced profitability
- greater regulation and compliance requirements
- uncertainty around future legislation
- concerns about the long-term viability of remaining in the sector
This suggests the core issue is not simply that holiday lets have become more attractive. It is that mainstream private renting has become more difficult, more expensive, and in some cases less appealing as an investment.
Dorset reflects the wider trend
In Dorset, those same pressures are being felt locally. There is evidence that a significant number of landlords in the area are considering leaving the market or reducing the number of properties they let. That matters because Dorset already faces housing affordability challenges, and any loss of long-term rental stock can intensify pressure on local tenants.
In areas like Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole, rents remain high and demand for housing is strong. That creates a difficult environment. If landlords pull back, tenants have fewer options. If even a modest number of properties move out of long-term use, competition for the remaining stock can increase further.
Is there strong evidence of a mass move into holiday lets?
This is where caution is needed.
There is good evidence that the South West has a large short-term lets market and that places such as Dorset have seen substantial growth in this area over recent years. In tourist hotspots, holiday accommodation is clearly an established and important part of the local property economy.
However, that is not the same as proving that most landlords leaving private renting are switching directly into holiday lets.
That distinction matters. A landlord exiting the private rented sector could be:
- selling to an owner-occupier
- selling to another landlord
- moving property into a company structure
- keeping the asset for personal use
- converting to short-term holiday accommodation
- waiting to see how the market changes
So while the idea of a direct shift from long-term renting to holiday lets is plausible in some locations, the evidence is still much stronger on landlord withdrawal from private renting generally than on a mass, proven migration into the holiday-let sector specifically.
Why holiday lets can still look attractive
Even without decisive proof of a widespread shift, it is easy to see why some landlords may be tempted.
In strong tourism markets, holiday lets can offer:
- the potential for higher income during busy seasons
- greater control over when the property is occupied
- more flexibility if the owner wants occasional personal use
- an alternative to the long-term responsibilities of managing a standard tenancy
For landlords who feel squeezed by regulation, tax and finance costs, that flexibility can be appealing. In a coastal market with reliable visitor demand, the holiday-let model may appear to offer a way to preserve returns while reducing some of the frustrations associated with traditional letting.
But holiday lets are not a simple escape route
That said, moving into short-term letting is not necessarily an easy or risk-free solution.
Holiday lets come with their own challenges, including:
- fluctuating occupancy levels
- seasonal income
- platform fees
- cleaning and changeover costs
- guest management
- tighter local scrutiny in some areas
- growing regulatory attention from government and councils
There have also been important tax and policy changes affecting holiday lets. That means the model is not as straightforwardly advantageous as it may once have seemed.
In other words, while holiday accommodation may look attractive on paper in certain locations, it is not a guaranteed solution for landlords under pressure. For some, selling entirely may still be the simpler option.
Why this issue matters so much in places like Dorset
In tourism-led areas, this debate is especially sensitive because the local housing market is already under strain.
Where housing supply is tight and affordability is poor, the loss of even a relatively small number of homes from the long-term rental market can have a noticeable effect. That is why concern about holiday lets tends to be strongest in coastal and rural communities where local wages often do not keep pace with housing costs.
The real issue is not whether holiday lets should exist. They are an important part of many local economies. The question is whether the balance has shifted too far in some places, making it harder for local people to find stable, affordable homes.
What is most likely happening now?
The most balanced conclusion is that landlords are clearly reassessing their future in the private rented sector. Some may well be moving into short-term holiday lets, particularly in attractive tourist locations. But the stronger evidence points to a broader retreat from private renting rather than a proven, large-scale transfer into holiday accommodation.
That means the concern is real, but the scale of the shift should not be overstated.
Could this become a bigger trend in the future?
Yes, it could.
If pressure on private landlords continues to increase, more owners may start looking at alternative uses for their properties, especially in areas where tourism demand is strong. If long-term letting becomes less profitable, less flexible, and more heavily regulated, then holiday accommodation may become more attractive by comparison.
That does not mean every landlord will make that move. But it does mean the risk of further switching remains credible, particularly in parts of the country where visitor demand is strong enough to support it.
Final thoughts
There is convincing evidence that many landlords are becoming less confident about staying in the private rented sector. There is also clear reason to believe that some will consider holiday lets as an alternative, especially in coastal markets such as Dorset.
What there is not, at least yet, is definitive proof that landlords are moving en masse from private rentals into short-term holiday accommodation.
For now, the clearest story is not one of a full-scale switch, but of a sector under pressure. And in places where housing is already scarce, even the possibility of more homes moving away from long-term renting is enough to raise serious questions about the future of local housing supply.
Disclaimer: NetRent does not provide legal advice and this article represents our understanding of the current rental property landscape.
Telephone: 01352 721300
Email: support@netrent.co.uk